I was somewhat surprised to learn about a month ago that restricted donations are not as restricted as I thought.
Before I continue, let me stress that the law differs from state to state and you should definitely consult a lawyer before even starting to entertain the idea of acting contrary to donor intent.
Essentially, my understanding has been that restrictions on donations are forever, but that is not necessarily the case. That knowledge potentially leaves some options available.
According to Charity Lawyer Ellis Carter, every state except PA has adopted a version of Uniform Prudent Management of Institutional Funds Act. The act is a model law, not a federal one with which states have aligned.
According to Carter, depending on your state:
A charity must follow a specific donor restriction, but it can ask a court to modify or release the restriction if it becomes impracticable, wasteful, or hard to administer.
In some cases it does not need a court. A charity can change a restriction on its own, without the donor’s consent and without telling the donor, if the fund is worth less than $25,000 and the gift is more than twenty years old. Only the attorney general has to be notified.
In general the Act is meant to ensure prudent use and investment of donor funds. While it is possible to release restrictions, the conditions are still pretty stringent. There is very little benefit in sitting on $25,000 for 20 years with the intent of redirecting the funds to other uses. But if the conditions have made the funds nigh impossible to use over the course of decades, at least there is an alternative available.
As I mentioned, every state is different and Ellis Carter addresses some of the differences and case studies in AZ and WA, the two states her office practices law in.
In AZ, the threshold is $50,000 rather than the $25,000 of the model legislation.
In WA the restriction can be modified without donor consent by requesting court modification and notifying the attorney general who can weigh in on the plan.
Carter briefly addresses the inclusion of reversion clauses in donation contracts by the donor who wishes to reinforce their intended use of the funds. She notes that for individuals, under US Treasury regulations if there is a chance the money won’t be used for the intended purpose, they wouldn’t be able to deduct the amount of the donation. (Presumably once the money has been used as intended they could, but I don’t know what the accounting rules for that might be.)
She notes that since the funds foundations distribute received a deduction when they were given to the foundation, requiring recipients to return unused funds is less problematic and just good grant making practice.


I wonder how much of that effect is due to people searching directly with search engines, rather than using the…