Narrow Options Exist For Use Of Restricted Funds

by:

Joe Patti

I was somewhat surprised to learn about a month ago that restricted donations are not as restricted as I thought.

Before I continue, let me stress that the law differs from state to state and you should definitely consult a lawyer before even starting to entertain the idea of acting contrary to donor intent.

Essentially, my understanding has been that restrictions on donations are forever, but that is not necessarily the case. That knowledge potentially leaves some options available.

According to Charity Lawyer Ellis Carter, every state except PA has adopted a version of Uniform Prudent Management of Institutional Funds Act. The act is a model law, not a federal one with which states have aligned.

According to Carter, depending on your state:

A charity must follow a specific donor restriction, but it can ask a court to modify or release the restriction if it becomes impracticable, wasteful, or hard to administer.

In some cases it does not need a court. A charity can change a restriction on its own, without the donor’s consent and without telling the donor, if the fund is worth less than $25,000 and the gift is more than twenty years old. Only the attorney general has to be notified.

In general the Act is meant to ensure prudent use and investment of donor funds. While it is possible to release restrictions, the conditions are still pretty stringent. There is very little benefit in sitting on $25,000 for 20 years with the intent of redirecting the funds to other uses. But if the conditions have made the funds nigh impossible to use over the course of decades, at least there is an alternative available.

As I mentioned, every state is different and Ellis Carter addresses some of the differences and case studies in AZ and WA, the two states her office practices law in.

In AZ, the threshold is $50,000 rather than the $25,000 of the model legislation.

In WA the restriction can be modified without donor consent by requesting court modification and notifying the attorney general who can weigh in on the plan.

Carter briefly addresses the inclusion of reversion clauses in donation contracts by the donor who wishes to reinforce their intended use of the funds. She notes that for individuals, under US Treasury regulations if there is a chance the money won’t be used for the intended purpose, they wouldn’t be able to deduct the amount of the donation. (Presumably once the money has been used as intended they could, but I don’t know what the accounting rules for that might be.)

She notes that since the funds foundations distribute received a deduction when they were given to the foundation, requiring recipients to return unused funds is less problematic and just good grant making practice.

Giving Art The London Treatment

by:

Joe Patti

Based on my experience running facilities that housed visual arts galleries I am aware that there are strict temperature and humidity requirements for galleries. Custodians of many collections won’t loan their works if you can not maintain temperature within +/- 2 degrees Celsius and +/- 5% humidity.

What I did not know, however, until a recent piece in The Art Newspaper, is that those standards were established in the 1970s based on the temperature and humidity of galleries in London.

There is a movement to establish more flexible standards because HVAC accounts for 60%-70% of museum facility energy consumption. As climate change concerns increase, there is a desire to avoid contributing to the situation. Museums in the US Southwest have an especially difficult time maintaining the standards established for London.

This is not to say museums are proposing moving to standards which may result in environmental damage to pieces of art. When I moved to the Mountain West I discovered some of the wooden works of art I owned were not formed of a single piece as I had assumed as they dried out and the seams became visible. Both lender and borrower want to avoid a similar experience.

Some lenders are increasingly willing to establish more flexible standards for the display and storage of works in their collections.

Tools have been developed to help museums gather data about the cost and savings they can experience running their HVAC at different settings.

Environment and Culture Partners (ECP) launched the Min/Max tool, which is designed to show institutions how alterations to their climate ranges might impact energy bills and carbon emissions, allowing users to input information like their HVAC system type, climate region and building specifications.

While the Min/Max tool can help improve operations, it can also assist in fundraising for climate initiatives. “We realised about five years ago that it’s hard to make a case for change without raw data,” says Sarah Sutton, a co-founder and the chief executive of ECP. “This is especially important for senior leadership like finance, who might not be in the climate discussion. If we can prove that you are going to save money, that might help get the entire museum on board.”

Outcomes Into Practice

by:

Joe Patti

Angela Meleca argues that arts entities need to focus on the outcomes of their programs which align with the things funders measure, including governments.

More importantly, as she noted in a post she made back in August, it isn’t enough to amplify those outcomes. They need to be put into meaningful practice.

She mentions a 36 page study conducted in Detroit that analyzed the positive outcomes of youth arts

“…nam[ing] attention, emotional regulation, belonging, collaboration, and future readiness as capacities every sector says young people lack right now”

But she says without someone putting this research into practice, things generally end with the analysis. She provides some examples of this information being put into practice with a focus on beneficial outcomes rather than funding arts as a solution.

Compare Greece.

Greece didn’t fund the arts. It funded a way to reduce relapses and ER visits — and wrote that into Law 5179/2025, integrated straight into the national e-prescription system. The art didn’t have to justify itself as art. It had to justify itself as a lever inside a health budget that already answers for relapse rates and ER volume.

Compare Visioning Beyond Violence.

Nobody asks a gun violence prevention program to prove its cultural value. They ask whether shootings go down. VBV doesn’t lead with “the arts matter.” It leads with public safety outcomes a mayor’s office already tracks — and the art is the delivery mechanism underneath.

Neither case made a better argument for art. Both started with a problem somebody already had a budget to solve.

This is not an approach have fully internalized and analyzed in a way I can have a clear, well-informed discussion of effective ways to apply and implement it. But what she suggests does seem to make sense.

I have often railed against the idea of using arts as a prescription in the sense that you just add Mozart and your kids becomes smarter or develop better socialization skills, etc. In the programs Meleca uses as examples, arts aren’t the only input. Arts aren’t present in a vacuum and expected to work. It is part of a whole toolbox which likely includes therapies, counseling, medications, curricula, community dialogues, etc.

I didn’t take a deep look at Greece’s law, but the Visioning Beyond Violence website has a lot of detail about the work they do. The arts are in there, but so are a lot of the other elements I list.

Talking About Budgets Without Getting Stuck In The Weeds

by:

Joe Patti

Caitlin Pontrella made a great post about the non-profit budgeting process about three weeks ago that I wanted to point out to readers. Though as I think about it, some of these suggestions can be applied to family budgeting process as well.

She titles her piece as three lessons for budgeting, but there are multiple subpoints. Her first point is about over-engineering the process and getting stuck in the weeds. She notes that while the common advice is to start early, she says if you are starting 6 months early on a budget, you should be able to have the big conversations that need to occur over the course of 2-3 iterations. In comments on her post, she says she has found that if the organization is hitting 4-5 iterations, there is probably a misalignment of budgeting priorities with strategy.

She advises focusing most the energy on the big cost drivers and revenue assumptions and quickly move past the budget lines that represent less than 5% of the budget.

• Focus on the assumptions
Every budget is built on assumptions about the business environment: customer and donor behaviors, enrollment targets, trends in the sector etc. Once you have a number, use your time pressure testing the underlying assumptions rather than tweaking the calcs.

Her second lesson is to treat the budgeting process as a teaching moment. This is the time to educate the board about industry trends, risks, priorities and get them in a place to exercise better governance.

To accomplish this, she advises using storytelling via dashboards, visuals and narratives rather than the raw accounting numbers. Regardless of how many different boards you directors have been on, make sure they know how your organization in particular navigates the operating environment — what challenges you face and what benefits you possess that allow you to breeze past things others may find to be an obstacle.

She also says that the board members shouldn’t be seeing the budget for the first time on the day they are voting to approve it. There should be plenty of time in advance for them to review the materials and formulate questions.

The third lesson to factor in human nature is one I appreciate most based on my experience. Since people have some programs or aspects of the organization they value most and feel invested in, there should be an opportunity to have small group conversations about difficult choices which need to be made.

Executives and board officers need to work together to socialize tough decisions before they hit the big room. This isn’t about stifling legitimate objections or backroom dealing. Rather, its about giving people a safer space to have their personal feelings heard. When people feel heard, they are much more capable of setting their feelings aside in the interest of the org in the more public setting.

Another important point she makes is that the board chair must control the direction of the conversation.

If a director starts defending their pet project, or the conversation gets entrenched in the ‘we’ve tried that before’ loop, or things take a turn for the personal, the board chair needs to redirect the conversation back to institutional strategy. It takes courage, but without this type of firm facilitation, the budget quickly becomes a proxy war for a wide array of personal agendas.

I should note that Pontrella’s lessons are derived from working on budgets for 13 different organizations both as board chair and chief executive. She specializes in interim executive management so she has racked up a fair big of experience in different scenarios in a relatively short period of time.