Blue Avocado looked at the IRS requirements for non-profit executive compensation. The IRS requires that the organization provide documentation showing how to arrived at a compensation level reasonable for that position.
But as the author Josh Green notes, many non-profits lack the funds to pay for access to compensation databases or engage a consultant. He said it took him three days to write a program to query a database of 990 filings in order to create a peer group for the non-profit board he sat on and none of his work would be usable by another non-profit.
Green says Googling for information doesn’t work because the results don’t account for organization size, location, or type of non-profits.
He says even if you are pulling 990 filings from other non-profits, boards are often looking at the wrong peer groups in terms of the aforementioned criteria. You can’t compare the executive director salary for an arts group with a $1 million budget in New England to a $10 million budget youth athletics organization in the Midwest.
Among the other poor decisions he says organizations make are allowing the executive director to be part of the compensation conversation, not documenting the process as required by the IRS, and not revisiting compensation after the first benchmarking exercise.
He lays out the three steps the IRS requires:
The three steps:
1. An independent body reviews the compensation. Board members or a compensation committee, composed of people with no conflict of interest. That rules out the person being paid.
2. That body obtains and relies on appropriate comparability data. Real data from similarly situated organizations (similar budget, sector, and geography), rather than a Google search or a single national average.
3. The body documents the basis for its decision. Meeting minutes that record what data was reviewed, who was involved, and what the board concluded.
None of this is complicated. But step two is where boards tend to get stuck, because “appropriate comparability data” is either expensive to buy or tedious to compile by hand.
He goes into more detail about how he would go about doing a compensation search today, noting AI tools can help eliminate some of the tedious steps and possibly reduce his three day effort to an afternoon.
He also mentions, he created a free tool to help non-profits create a PeerSet for compensation studies for 12 different job roles.


I wonder how much of that effect is due to people searching directly with search engines, rather than using the…