What Will Be The Toughest Things To Explain Without Back-Up Records

by:

Joe Patti

As something of a complement to my post yesterday about collecting compensation comparables (alliteration intended) for executive salaries. Eliis Carter made had a post around the same time as the Blue Avocado piece I cited in which she talked about good record keeping from the context of board meeting minutes.

She also mentions collecting compensation data but stresses the importance of the minutes reflecting who was present, who recused themselves, any conflicts of interest, the rationale behind the use of the data, among other considerations. She warns against a summary stating there was a discussion and the board approved.

Her general theme in the post is that it isn’t enough to just have policies, there need to be records of them being followed. If the board has a conflict of interest policy, there should be a file of signed annual statements of conflicts.

If there is a record retention policy there should be evidence that records are being stored and destroyed according to that policy. Any documents that were distributed during a meeting should accompany the corresponding meeting minutes.

If the bylaws are changed, there should be a record of the recommendations of the committee report, discussion of the recommendations, rationale presented for the changes, general thoughts and concerns expressed. Again – who was present for the discussions, who recused, etc.

Carter offers the following advice for ensuring your board is “showing their work.” My emphasis on the first sentence because I think that is a great starting criterion.

Practical Steps to Show Your Work
Start by picking the five or six things your organization would least want to explain without paperwork. For most nonprofits these are executive compensation, related party transactions, foreign or sanctions-sensitive grants, federal award certifications, and restricted gifts. For each one, ask what record exists today that would show a careful decision was made.

Then set a habit. Have directors and key staff sign conflict of interest disclosures every year. Draft minutes within a few weeks of each meeting and approve them at the next one. Keep a compliance calendar and a simple log of screenings, policy reviews, and training. Store everything somewhere that does not depend on one person’s laptop or email account. Review the policies themselves at least once a year to confirm they match what the organization actually does.

IRS Proofing Non-Profit Executive Compensation

by:

Joe Patti

Blue Avocado looked at the IRS requirements for non-profit executive compensation. The IRS requires that the organization provide documentation showing how to arrived at a compensation level reasonable for that position.

But as the author Josh Green notes, many non-profits lack the funds to pay for access to compensation databases or engage a consultant. He said it took him three days to write a program to query a database of 990 filings in order to create a peer group for the non-profit board he sat on and none of his work would be usable by another non-profit.

Green says Googling for information doesn’t work because the results don’t account for organization size, location, or type of non-profits.

He says even if you are pulling 990 filings from other non-profits, boards are often looking at the wrong peer groups in terms of the aforementioned criteria. You can’t compare the executive director salary for an arts group with a $1 million budget in New England to a $10 million budget youth athletics organization in the Midwest.

Among the other poor decisions he says organizations make are allowing the executive director to be part of the compensation conversation, not documenting the process as required by the IRS, and not revisiting compensation after the first benchmarking exercise.

He lays out the three steps the IRS requires:

The three steps:

1.  An independent body reviews the compensation. Board members or a compensation committee, composed of people with no conflict of interest. That rules out the person being paid.

2.  That body obtains and relies on appropriate comparability data. Real data from similarly situated organizations (similar budget, sector, and geography), rather than a Google search or a single national average.

3.  The body documents the basis for its decision. Meeting minutes that record what data was reviewed, who was involved, and what the board concluded.

None of this is complicated. But step two is where boards tend to get stuck, because “appropriate comparability data” is either expensive to buy or tedious to compile by hand.

He goes into more detail about how he would go about doing a compensation search today, noting AI tools can help eliminate some of the tedious steps and possibly reduce his three day effort to an afternoon.

He also mentions, he created a free tool to help non-profits create a PeerSet for compensation studies for 12 different job roles.

Not All Copyright Claims Have Right To Collect

by:

Joe Patti

Entertainment lawyer Gordon Firemark made a recent post about copyright demands for images used in blog posts or podcasts.

For me it was somewhat timely because we had recently gotten takedown requests for posts that supposedly appeared on our Facebook page. The requests were from what appeared to be an AI company, but they were citing Korean copyright law.

While they provided links to what they claimed to be proof, we had a high suspicion about downloading some malicious software or something similar and passed the whole thing on to our attorney. The only thing we thought might be related to this request was an upcoming performance by a Korean artist. But the only thing we posted related to him was a photo he provided, re-posting a video he made encouraging people to see ten upcoming performances, and a localized video he sent us mentioning the show at our venue.

We are still not clear what it was all about. My suspicion is that since facial recognition software is notoriously bad with East Asian faces, there is some automated mistaken identity going on here.

In any case, not to bury the lede too much more, Firemark’s advice is:

The short answer: If you get a demand letter over an image on your podcast art, show notes or blog, don’t ignore it and don’t pay it yet. Take the image down, preserve your records, and ask the sender for three things: proof of U.S. copyright registration, proof of its legal authority to act for the owner, and the image’s real licensing history. Without those, there’s no way to know whether the claim is worth settling, or for how much.

Firemark notes that the claim you used an image and that you owe X amount are two different issues. You may have used the image without permission, but he says, the amount they claim is owed often isn’t the value of the usage.

He says the number is calculated based on the estimate of what you will pay not to go to court. He uses the example – if going to court will cost you $5000, but they say you owe $1500, that seems like a bargain. But the actual fee for the use of the image may be far lower than $1500.

He also warns that paying the wrong entity doesn’t alleviate your responsibility to the real owner. This is why it is important to get proof the entity pressing the claim has authority to act for the owner. Someone may be responsible for preventing the use of the material, but not collecting on the behalf of the owner.

Many artist contracts with performing arts venues require the venue to prevent the recording of the performance or other associated intellectual property, but doesn’t empower them to press for compensation.

Firemark writes: (my emphasis)

Under the Copyright Act, only the legal or beneficial owner of an exclusive right can sue. The Ninth Circuit has held that someone who is handed just the “right to sue,” without any actual ownership interest, has no standing (Silvers v. Sony; Righthaven v. Hoehn). An enforcement agency’s letter should come with the agreement showing who owns the image and what authority the agency really has. If it can’t produce that, you can’t be sure a payment resolves anything.

Obviously much more complicated a situation than I have depicted here so read the post and consult an attorney.

Making Internships Meaningful

by:

Joe Patti

Recently someone on Reddit posted an excerpt from Emily The Criminal where Aubrey Plaza’s character is told the job she is interviewing for is an internship that will last 5-6 months before they decide whether it is worth paying her. The scene is definitely written to be a little ragebaity except that I am sure it isn’t too far off from real life conversations that have transpired.

The posting seemed serendipitous with an article posted on ArtsMidwest authored by the person who runs the intern program at the Children’s Museum of Indianapolis. While they reference some of the general Fair Labor and Standards Act rules about internships I have written about previously, the general approach of the piece is to make internships more valuable for all.

One of the first points author Matt Inpongpan makes is that paid internships not only make the internship accessible to a wider range of people with differing levels of financial means, the payment element often causes the host organization to take the role more seriously. Paid interns tend to get trusted with more responsibility, access, and authority

Inpongpan says his organization requires clear guidelines and expectations for the internship be established, including the non-negotiable inclusion of a learning outcome. “If a role isn’t built for learning, or it has outgrown the internship, make it a job.”

Inpongpan also writes that mentors should be subject to as much preparation and accountability as interns are.

That starts before kickoff, with mentor prep that includes guidance on building relationships. I won’t pretend we’ve figured it all out. But I do know that nothing shapes an intern’s experience more than an engaged mentor.

Mentors get a lot back too, including fresh perspectives from people just entering the field…For staff who don’t otherwise supervise anyone, that’s a first taste of managing and hiring. Accountability runs both ways as well. At the end, interns rate their mentors on things like introducing them to colleagues, giving recognition, and offering real challenges.

Inpongpan shares a few of their successful practices like providing interns with a one-sheet of advice compiled from previous interns. He notes that the organization also implements suggestions made by prior interns like bringing interns to meetings that aren’t related to their project in order to provide a broader perspective.

Among the other practices he shares are tailoring the task to the intern, having periodic check-ins, introducing the intern around to other staff, and involving them.

Many of them seem obvious, but are good reminders. There was one that particularly caught my eye because it is so easy to violate in a busy non-profit arts environment where everyone is pressed to complete a multitude of tasks:

Protect non-task time.

Shared lunches and cohort events are the first things cut when schedules fill up. They’re also where community forms. When interns are learning and feel like part of the team, the work gets done.

Here is the very pointed excerpt from Emily the Criminal:

123…815 Next