As something of a complement to my post yesterday about collecting compensation comparables (alliteration intended) for executive salaries. Eliis Carter made had a post around the same time as the Blue Avocado piece I cited in which she talked about good record keeping from the context of board meeting minutes.
She also mentions collecting compensation data but stresses the importance of the minutes reflecting who was present, who recused themselves, any conflicts of interest, the rationale behind the use of the data, among other considerations. She warns against a summary stating there was a discussion and the board approved.
Her general theme in the post is that it isn’t enough to just have policies, there need to be records of them being followed. If the board has a conflict of interest policy, there should be a file of signed annual statements of conflicts.
If there is a record retention policy there should be evidence that records are being stored and destroyed according to that policy. Any documents that were distributed during a meeting should accompany the corresponding meeting minutes.
If the bylaws are changed, there should be a record of the recommendations of the committee report, discussion of the recommendations, rationale presented for the changes, general thoughts and concerns expressed. Again – who was present for the discussions, who recused, etc.
Carter offers the following advice for ensuring your board is “showing their work.” My emphasis on the first sentence because I think that is a great starting criterion.
Practical Steps to Show Your Work
Start by picking the five or six things your organization would least want to explain without paperwork. For most nonprofits these are executive compensation, related party transactions, foreign or sanctions-sensitive grants, federal award certifications, and restricted gifts. For each one, ask what record exists today that would show a careful decision was made.
Then set a habit. Have directors and key staff sign conflict of interest disclosures every year. Draft minutes within a few weeks of each meeting and approve them at the next one. Keep a compliance calendar and a simple log of screenings, policy reviews, and training. Store everything somewhere that does not depend on one person’s laptop or email account. Review the policies themselves at least once a year to confirm they match what the organization actually does.


I wonder how much of that effect is due to people searching directly with search engines, rather than using the…